How Collectible Pins Are Made: A Step-by-Step Behind-the-Scenes Look

How Collectible Pins Are Made: A Step-by-Step Behind-the-Scenes Look

Collectible pins have become a cultural staple—loved by hobbyists, fashion lovers, event organizers, and fandom communities alike. From enamel lapel pins to limited-edition trading pins, each tiny piece of art represents creativity, craftsmanship, and careful manufacturing. But how exactly are collectible pins made?

In this behind-the-scenes guide, we’ll walk through the step-by-step process that takes a pin from concept to collectible.

1. Concept & Design: Where the Artwork Begins

Every pin starts with a concept—an illustration, logo, character, or visual idea. Designers typically create vector artwork so manufacturers can scale and separate colors precisely.

Key steps in this stage:

  • Brainstorming concepts and themes

  • Sketching initial ideas

  • Digitizing artwork in vector format (AI, EPS, SVG)

  • Choosing colors from the Pantone color chart

  • Finalizing the technical blueprint for production

This is also where you decide: soft enamel or hard enamel, die-struck metal or printed, matte or glossy plating—all of which affect the final look.

2. Mold Creation: Carving the Pin’s Blueprint

Once the artwork is approved, the manufacturer creates a mold. This mold is essentially a metal stamp that presses the design into the pin’s base material (usually brass, iron, or zinc alloy).

How the mold is made:

  • A CNC machine or chemical etching process carves the design into steel

  • Raised and recessed areas are defined

  • The mold is heat-treated to withstand multiple uses

Think of it like creating a cookie cutter—only far more precise and durable.

3. Stamping or Die-Casting: Forming the Pin’s Shape

With the mold ready, it’s time to press the design into metal.

Stamping

For simpler designs and most enamel pins, a metal sheet is placed under the mold and stamped to create the raised design.

Die-Casting

For more intricate shapes and 3D pins, molten metal is poured into the mold instead.

This step creates the physical metal base of the pin—complete with all the lines and borders that will later hold the enamel.

4. Cutting & Trimming: Perfecting the Outline

After stamping or casting, the pins are cut from the metal sheet. A secondary mold or cutting tool is used to trim them into their final shape—circle, square, custom silhouette, etc.

Any rough edges are:

  • Sanded

  • Polished

  • Refined for smoothness

This ensures the pin feels premium in your hand.

5. Plating: Giving the Metal Its Shine

Plating determines the pin’s metal finish. The pin bases are dipped in a solution using electroplating, bonding the chosen metal onto the surface.

Popular plating options:

  • Gold

  • Silver

  • Black nickel

  • Rose gold

  • Antique finishes (vintage gold, bronze, copper)

The plate not only affects the aesthetics but also protects the pin from corrosion.

6. Enameling: Adding Color & Depth

This is the most visually exciting step—the colors come in!

Soft Enamel Pins

  • Enamel is added to recessed areas

  • Metal borders remain raised

  • Creates a textured, dimensional surface

Soft enamel is popular for its classic pin-trading look.

Hard Enamel Pins

  • Enamel is added and polished flat

  • Smooth, jewelry-like finish

  • Durable and scratch-resistant

Colors are filled one by one, often by hand, using tiny syringes or automated dispensers.

7. Baking & Polishing: Locking In the Color

After coloring, pins go into a high-temperature oven to cure the enamel. This hardens the colors and secures them into place.

Hard enamel pins undergo an extra step: polishing, which smooths the surface until metal and enamel are flush.

8. Adding the Backing: Making the Pin Wearable

The attachment—known as the pin back—gets soldered or glued on. The most common backings include:

  • Rubber clutch

  • Butterfly clutch

  • Deluxe metal clutch

  • Magnetic backing

  • Safety pin-style bar

Each offers different levels of hold, comfort, and aesthetic.

9. Quality Control: Ensuring Each Pin Is Collectible-Grade

Manufacturers inspect each pin carefully, checking for:

  • Accurate color fill

  • Clean metal lines

  • Smooth plating

  • Proper backing attachment

  • No scratches, dust, or imperfections

Pins that don’t meet the standard are discarded or sold as seconds.

10. Packaging: The Final Touch

Finally, pins are mounted on backing cards, sealed in protective bags, or boxed for collectors.

Good packaging can enhance:

  • Brand presentation

  • Collectibility

  • Gift appeal

Final Thoughts

Collectible pins might be small, but they’re crafted through a thoughtful, detailed process involving art, engineering, and craftsmanship. Whether you’re designing your first pin or simply appreciate the hobby, knowing how pins are made adds a whole new layer of appreciation.

Want help designing a pin or writing product descriptions for your pin shop? I’d be happy to help!

Back to blog