How to Start a Pin Collection on Any Budget (Yes, Even $0!)

How to Start a Pin Collection on Any Budget (Yes, Even $0!)

Enamel pins have exploded in popularity over the last decade—and for good reason. They’re tiny, wearable pieces of art that let you show off your personality, fandoms, memories, and sense of humor all at once. The best part? You don’t need a big budget to start (or grow) an amazing collection. Here’s a complete guide for every price point, from completely free to “treat yourself” level.

Level 0: $0 – Start Completely Free

You can absolutely begin collecting without spending a cent.

  1. Pin trades & gifting communities
    • Join Facebook groups like “Enamel Pin Swap & Trade USA” or “Enamel Pin Trading Worldwide.”
    • Post an “ISO/FT” (In Search Of / For Trade) with things you already own: extra pins, stickers, patches, art prints, or even handmade items.
    • Reddit: r/pinswap, r/enamelpins, and fandom-specific subs often have free giveaway threads.
  2. Pin mail / pen-pal programs
    • Sites like sendsomething.net or Postcrossing sometimes include pins.
    • Many artists run “pin pal” events on Instagram where you send one pin and receive a different one back.
  3. Ask friends & family
    • Someone always has a dusty Disney lanyard or old concert pins they’ll happily give away.
  4. Freebie hunting
    • Check event goodie bags, conference swag tables, or even the lost-and-found at conventions (ask nicely!).

Level 1: $1–$25 – The Scrappy Starter Budget

This is where most collectors begin.

  1. Mystery packs & seconds sales
    • Artists sell “mystery grab bags” ($5–$15) and “B-grade” (slightly imperfect) pins at huge discounts.
  2. AliExpress / Temu / Shein
    • You can get cute (often unlicensed) pins for $0.50–$2 each. Great for display boards when you’re just starting out and want quantity.
  3. Etsy “bulk lots”
    • Search “enamel pin lot” or “pin destash.” People regularly sell 10–20 pins for $15–$25 shipped.
  4. Thrift stores & yard sales
    • Hard Rock café pins, old political campaigns, vintage scout pins—tons of character for pennies.

Level 2: $25–$100 – The Thoughtful Collector

Now you’re buying pins you actually love.

  1. Support small artists directly
    • Most independent pin makers price pins $8–$12. Follow artists on Instagram and catch early-bird or flash sales.
  2. Shop sales & conventions
    • Black Friday, artist alley end-of-con tables, and Patreon-exclusive discounts can cut prices 30–50%.
  3. Subscription boxes (optional)
    • Boxes like Pinscription, Critit Pins, or fandom-specific ones usually run $20–$40/month and feel like a treat.
  4. Locking backs upgrade
    • Spend $5–$10 once on high-quality locking pin backs (from Pin Game Strong or LuxCups). They protect your collection forever.

Level 3: $100+ – The “I’m Invested Now” Phase

You’re curating, not just collecting.

  1. Limited-edition & fantasy pins
    • Official Disney fantasy pins, graded collaboration drops, artist proofs (APs), or rare older designs.
  2. Custom pins
    • Making your own design starts around $100–$200 for 50–100 pieces (great if you want to trade).
  3. Display upgrades
    • Banner boards (Etsy has gorgeous ones), itabags, shadow boxes, or rotating pin frames.

Pro Tips That Save Money at Every Level

  • Set a theme early (cats, plants, 80s nostalgia, national parks, etc.). It keeps you from impulse-buying everything cute.
  • Always check the back stamp. Official Disney pins, Hard Rock, or recognizable makers hold value better if you ever sell/trade.
  • Photograph new additions immediately for insurance purposes (and for posting on r/enamelpins or #pinmail on Instagram).
  • Use the “one in, one out” rule once your board is full—sell or trade older pins to fund new ones.
  • Join pin Discord servers. People post “damaged in mail” pins they’ll send you for just shipping cost.

Where to Display Your Growing Collection

  • Cork boards or foam boards with fabric covering (under $15)
  • Thrifted picture frames with foam inserts
  • Japanese-style itabags (clear backpacks/bags made for pins)
  • Jackets, hats, lanyards, or banner flags if you prefer wearable displays

Final Thought

The “perfect” collection isn’t the most expensive—it’s the one that makes you smile every time you look at it. Whether you started with a single gifted pin or a $200 artist drop, every collector began exactly where you are right now.

Happy pinning—may your boards always be full and your backing cards never lost! 🧷✨

Which budget level are you starting at? Drop a comment below with your first theme idea—I’d love to hear it!

Back to blog